From Hamilton Beach to Black + Decker, toaster ovens are a convenient and easy to use kitchen tool to add additional oven space and versatility to your kitchen. Depending on the size and features of the model in question, they can provide a place to cook an additional dish or two, reheat leftovers, or cook entire meals for an individual or couple. This makes them a worthwhile investment for those just getting started, living in small spaces, or large families who enjoy entertaining.
Countertop space is a precious resource in most of our kitchens today, so it’s imperative to know which oven is the best investment for your home.
View The Best Toaster Oven Under $100 Below
1. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven
Big utility in a small package makes this Hamilton Beach Countertop Oven one of the best toaster ovens available for under $100. The oven comes with features that allow you to toast, broil, bake, and handle convection cooking, as well as two rack positions, making it a versatile tool. With a capacity built to handle a 9″ x 11″ baking sheet or a 12-inch pizza without a problem, it can easily take the place of a full-sized oven for a micro kitchen or small living space.
The Hamilton Beach toaster oven’s roll-up door keeps spills and drips from sticking to the door, and the removable crumb tray pulls out from the front to make cleaning up a breeze.
+ Large capacity oven
+ Includes convection oven feature
+ Crumb tray makes cleaning easy
Why We Like It – This Hamilton Beach toaster oven packs a lot of utility into a small, easy to use, appliance.
2. Nostalgia RTOV2AQ Multi-Functioning Retro Convection Toaster Oven
Who needs to fire up the bigger stove when you can bake two 12-inch pizzas or 12 slices of bread in a smaller, more efficient countertop oven with a retro twist? This toaster oven comes in just under $100, and it can do a lot with a little space. With a heating capacity up to 450 degrees, an hour-long timer setting, and two adjustable racks, the Nostalgia RTOV2AQ packs everything you need to cook for two people into a package you can fit in less than two feet of countertop.
Both racks and the removable crumb tray provide easy clean up, and an indicator light prevents the oven from being left on accidentally.
+ Large capacity oven
+ Includes convection oven feature
+ Cute retro design
+ Indicator light tells you when it is on
Why We Like It – This toaster oven adds utility to your kitchen as well as a charming, retro touch.
3. Dash Mini Toaster Oven Cooker
Is a toaster oven with a foot and a half width too large for your kitchen? Do you have a picky eater and want to give them a means of fixing their own meal independently? The Dash Mini Toaster Oven may be the best toaster oven for you.
The simple design, automatic shut off function, and miniature size makes this the perfect starter toaster oven for those just learning to cook or moving out on their own. While small, this toaster oven comes with an adjustable rack, removable crumb tray, cooking sheet, and access to a recipe database.
+ Compact design
+ Four color options
+ Includes a recipe book and recipe database access
+ 1-year manufacturer warranty
Why We Like It – Smaller than the earlier entries on this list, the Dash Mini Toaster Oven is perfect for families with a picky eater or micro-kitchens without space for a larger option.
4. HomeLabs Digital Countertop Convection Oven
If you want a toaster oven with a precise, easy to read digital display instead of traditional dials that can be ambiguous, this toaster oven is an excellent choice under $100.
The stainless steel exterior stylishly fits in with modern kitchen decor. With three possible rack positions, the oven can toast six slices of bread at once or handle a full rotisserie chicken. It has a clear, digital LCD display, ten cooking functions, and a heating range up to 450 degrees, making it easy to toast, bake, or broil.
The toaster oven comes with a bakeware pan, broiler rack, rotisserie fork, and removable crumb tray.
+ Stainless steel exterior for today’s kitchens
+ 3 rack positions
+ Clear digital LCD display for easy use
Why We Like It – The HomeLabs Digital Countertop Convection Oven is one of the best choices for those who want more precise control than is possible with traditional dials.
5. Oster Digital Toaster Oven
What large family, or entertaining enthusiast, would not want an extra, miniature oven come time for holiday gatherings? The Oster Toaster Oven combines a sleek black exterior with stainless steel accents with the versatility of a full-sized oven, packed into a small package.
Toast six slices of bread or a 12-inch pizza. With digital controls for seven cooking settings and a range of 150-450 degrees, you can cook just about anything you want, so long as it can fit into a 9-inch by 11-inch casserole dish up to 2 inches deep. Plus, the interior light makes it easy to keep an eye on what you’re cooking without having to open the oven.
+ Black and stainless steel exterior
+ Two rack positions
+ Interior light for easy monitoring
Why We Like It – With seven settings, wide temperature range, a large interior, and even an internal light, the Oster Toaster Oven is like a miniature oven for your countertop.
6. Luby 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven
What if you want your toaster oven to be able to handle deep dishes or to roast an entire chicken? With a height capable of accommodating a dish depth up to 11 inches, the Luby 6-Slice Toaster Oven may be the best toaster oven for you.
This toaster oven does more than merely toast up to six slices of bread at a time. It has four heating elements and a maximum heat capacity of 450 degrees, so you can bake, cook, or broil.
The oven features a 60-minute timer with a bell loud enough to ensure you’ll never miss it. It comes with an adjustable rack, a baking pan, and a crumb tray, all non-stick coated to make clean up easy.
+ Convection toaster oven
+ Two rack positions
+ Non-stick interior
Why We Like It – This is the toaster oven for those who want the flexibility to accommodate deep dishes.
7. Oster Convection Toaster Oven
Today’s busy lives and demanding schedules have spelled doom for many dinners. If this has been an issue for you or a loved one, look into this toaster oven. Working as both a toaster oven and a conventional cooker for fast and even cooking, it helps you make meals with ease in no time at all. Plus, it includes a 60-minute timer, an automatic shut-off feature, and an indicator light to help you avoid dinner disasters if multitasking puts you off track.
With two rack positions, a crumb tray that is removable for easy cleaning, and a baking pan included, this toaster oven has everything you need, from making toast to cooking a small roast.
+ Brushed stainless steel exterior
+ Two rack adjustments
+ Equipped with auto shut-off
Why We Like It – Attractively built with durability and safety in mind, this is the toaster oven for those who can get sidetracked.
8. Black+Decker Convection Countertop Toaster Oven
Purchasing a toaster oven should make the need for a toaster unnecessary, right? Yet, many of these toaster ovens take trial and error to find the perfect settings to use for your morning toast. That is not the case with this model. The Black + Decker TO324OXSBD comes with a dial dedicated to toast settings, making it a toast lover’s dream.
But, it still carries the other features that make toaster ovens so useful. It’s a touch wider than many other models, making it capable of fitting most standard 9-inch by 13-inch baking pans. Plus, it has four settings to warm, toast, broil, and bake.
+ Black and stainless steel exterior
+ Dedicated toast dial
+ Fits 9″ x 13″ pans
Why We Like It – If you want a toaster oven that takes toast as seriously as the other things it can cook, this is the toaster oven for you.
9. Maxi-Matic ERO-2008N Countertop Toaster Oven
If you love rotisserie chicken, this option should be at the top of your list of toaster ovens to consider. With five cooking settings, including dedicated rotisserie tools with the oven itself and the space to accommodate an entire chicken, it’s more than just a means to make toast.
Settings include toast, bake, broil, rotisserie, and another to keep food warm. In addition to the rotisserie tools, it includes a pull out crumb and drip tray for easy cleaning. It has an internal light, to make keeping an eye on your food as it cooks simple, and a timer to prevent overcooking.
+ Includes rotisserie tools
+ Slide out crumb and drip tray for easy cleaning
+ Interior light makes it easy to keep an eye on food
Why We Like It – This is one of the top toaster ovens for those who love rotisserie cooking. Make your own rotisserie chicken at home.
10. Mueller Austria Toaster Oven
Here is an option for those with limited space in their kitchen. While smaller than many of the other models listed, this toaster oven can still toast up to four slices of bread at a time, or roast enough vegetables for two adult dinners. Due to its small size, it’s faster and more energy-efficient than a full-sized oven, which can save you money over the long run and help keep your kitchen cooler during the summer months.
The dual position rack options make it simple to adjust cooking. A removable tray to catch crumbs and drips makes it easy to keep clean.
+ Small for kitchens with limited space
+ Dual position rack for an adjustable cooking
+ Energy efficient cooking
Why We Like It – This is one of the best choices for those with limited space and power for a toaster oven in their kitchen.
Toaster Oven Under $100 Buyer’s Guide
Individual kitchens and different families all have varying needs, so determining which are the best toaster ovens out there is a bit more complicated than pointing to a specific model and saying, “That one.” To determine which toaster oven is the best one for you and your family, you will need to consider your family’s needs and the available space in your kitchen.
Exactly what do you want and need out of a toaster oven? Will it simply be an alternate means to bake, broil, and reheat food, or does your living space not have room for a full-sized oven? The more things you want your toaster oven to do, the more features you need to search for when comparing different toaster ovens to fit your cooking needs. This must also be balanced with the amount of counter space you are able to devote to your future toaster oven.
What is the best toaster oven Consumer Reports?
Consumer Reports’ toaster oven testing does not limit itself to just the more affordable models under $100, as we have done on this list. Toaster ovens come in a wide variety of sizes, capacities, and with a broad range of features, meaning many of the best toaster ovens on the market go for well over $100, with some reaching over $400. As such, most, if not all, of the models ranking high on Consumer Reports’ list of toaster ovens fall outside the scope of this list. That said, there is a bit of overlap between the two lists, especially within a few key brands.
The Hamilton Beach 6-slice 31411 toaster oven makes the list despite being more “limited” than some of the other toaster ovens tested. This Hamilton Beach toaster oven is affordable, while still performing well for food reheating. This is as well as being easy to use to bake, broil, and toast batches of food.
Are toaster ovens worth it?
The answer to this question is personal to each family. Whether or not a toaster oven is worth the expense will depend on your needs, what you want out of the appliance, and the amount of counter space you have available. A toaster oven is an excellent investment for an individual, a couple, or a large family with the countertop real estate available for one.
Toaster ovens are an excellent means of reheating, baking, broiling, or toasting small to medium batches efficiently. You can cook for a large family or gathering, and it also provides a quick and easy means of cooking for one or two people without the excess heat a full-sized oven can generate. This also makes toaster ovens ideal for small living spaces where one cannot squeeze a full-sized oven.
Today’s toaster ovens offer a wide range of settings, tools, and options not available in past years’ models. They must justify taking up the valuable real estate that is countertop space in modern kitchens with our larger array of kitchen appliances and gadgets. Therefore, it is not always easy to determine which option is the most useful for you and your family, and this can be even more challenging on a budget.
This is why we invested the time and resources into researching the different models available for $100 or less to determine the ten best ovens for you to consider. Please use the information listed above and throughout the buyer’s guide to help narrow down your search and find the model with the best return on investment for your household.